Welcome back to the insanity that is Screen Scholars March Madness. For this “game” we’ll need you to pick the top show in the Crime! division. Which show won the last round, from our opening day game? Click on to see below the fold.

Comedy was the victor in our inaugural game of the season: Brooklyn Nine-Nine collared a win with 75 percent of the vote. Dirty John, the scintillating true-crime soap opera was guilty of a win with 53.8 percent of the vote. I’ll credit Connie Britton’s hair, though it’s a shame Handsome Mahershala wasn’t enough.

Will the comedy cop show win the title for our Crime division, or will the podcast-turned-Bravo-serial cause an upset? Only you can solve this case!